Server: add tests for batch size, different seeds (#6950)

examples/server/tests/features/results.feature

@@ -7,44 +7,16 @@ Feature: Results
     And   a model file tinyllamas/split/stories15M-00001-of-00003.gguf from HF repo ggml-org/models
     And   a model file test-model-00001-of-00003.gguf
     And   128 as batch size
-    And   256 KV cache size
+    And   1024 KV cache size
     And   128 max tokens to predict
-
-  Scenario Outline: Multi users completion
-    Given <n_slots> slots
     And   continuous batching
+
+  Scenario Outline: consistent results with same seed
+    Given <n_slots> slots
     Then  the server is starting
     Then  the server is healthy
 
-    Given 42 as seed
+    Given 4 prompts "Title: Little Red Riding Hood But In Space\n\nSummary:" with seed 42
-    And a prompt:
-      """
-      Write a very long story about AI.
-      """
-
-    Given 42 as seed
-    And a prompt:
-      """
-      Write a very long story about AI.
-      """
-
-    Given 42 as seed
-    And a prompt:
-      """
-      Write a very long story about AI.
-      """
-
-    Given 42 as seed
-    And a prompt:
-      """
-      Write a very long story about AI.
-      """
-
-    Given 42 as seed
-    And a prompt:
-      """
-      Write a very long story about AI.
-      """
 
     Given concurrent completion requests
     Then the server is busy
@@ -55,3 +27,55 @@ Feature: Results
       | n_slots |
       | 1       |
       | 2       |
+
+  Scenario Outline: different results with different seed
+    Given <n_slots> slots
+    Then  the server is starting
+    Then  the server is healthy
+
+    Given 1 prompts "Title: Little Red Riding Hood But In Space\n\nSummary:" with seed 42
+    Given 1 prompts "Title: Little Red Riding Hood But In Space\n\nSummary:" with seed 43
+    Given 1 prompts "Title: Little Red Riding Hood But In Space\n\nSummary:" with seed 44
+    Given 1 prompts "Title: Little Red Riding Hood But In Space\n\nSummary:" with seed 45
+
+    Given concurrent completion requests
+    Then the server is busy
+    Then the server is idle
+    And  all slots are idle
+    Then all predictions are different
+    Examples:
+      | n_slots |
+      | 1       |
+      | 2       |
+
+  Scenario Outline: consistent results with same seed and varying batch size
+    Given 4 slots
+    And   <temp> temperature
+    # And   0 as draft
+    Then  the server is starting
+    Then  the server is healthy
+
+    Given 1 prompts "Write a very long story about AI." with seed 42
+    And   concurrent completion requests
+    # Then the server is busy # Not all slots will be utilized.
+    Then  the server is idle
+    And   all slots are idle
+
+    Given <n_parallel> prompts "Write a very long story about AI." with seed 42
+    And   concurrent completion requests
+    # Then the server is busy # Not all slots will be utilized.
+    Then the server is idle
+    And  all slots are idle
+
+    Then all predictions are equal
+    Examples:
+      | n_parallel | temp |
+      |  1         | 0.0  |
+      |  2         | 0.0  |
+      |  4         | 0.0  |
+      |  1         | 1.0  |
+      # FIXME: These tests fail on master. The problem seems to be the unified KV cache.
+      # See https://github.com/ggerganov/whisper.cpp/issues/1941#issuecomment-1986923227
+      # and https://github.com/ggerganov/llama.cpp/pull/6122#discussion_r1531405574 .
+      # |  2         | 1.0  |
+      # |  4         | 1.0  |

examples/server/tests/features/steps/steps.py

@@ -65,6 +65,7 @@ def step_server_config(context, server_fqdn, server_port):
     context.server_seed = None
     context.user_api_key = None
     context.response_format = None
+    context.temperature = None
 
     context.tasks_result = []
     context.concurrent_tasks = []
@@ -232,15 +233,17 @@ async def step_all_slots_status(context, expected_slot_status_string):
 @async_run_until_complete
 async def step_request_completion(context, api_error):
     expect_api_error = api_error == 'raised'
+    seeds = await completions_seed(context, num_seeds=1)
     completion = await request_completion(context.prompts.pop(),
+                                          seeds[0] if seeds is not None else seeds,
                                           context.base_url,
                                           debug=context.debug,
                                           n_predict=context.n_predict,
                                           cache_prompt=context.cache_prompt,
                                           id_slot=context.id_slot,
-                                          seed=await completions_seed(context),
                                           expect_api_error=expect_api_error,
-                                          user_api_key=context.user_api_key)
+                                          user_api_key=context.user_api_key,
+                                          temperature=context.temperature)
     context.tasks_result.append(completion)
     if context.debug:
         print(f"Completion response: {completion}")
@@ -269,6 +272,15 @@ async def step_predictions_equal(context):
     context.tasks_result = []
 
 
+@step('all predictions are different')
+@async_run_until_complete
+async def step_predictions_equal(context):
+    n_completions = await gather_tasks_results(context)
+    assert n_completions >= 2, "need at least 2 completions"
+    assert_all_predictions_different(context.tasks_result)
+    context.tasks_result = []
+
+
 @step('the completion is  truncated')
 def step_assert_completion_truncated(context):
     step_assert_completion_truncated(context, '')
@@ -311,6 +323,11 @@ def step_response_format(context, response_format):
     context.response_format = json.loads(response_format)
 
 
+@step('{temperature:f} temperature')
+def step_temperature(context, temperature):
+    context.temperature = temperature
+
+
 @step('streaming is {enable_streaming}')
 def step_streaming(context, enable_streaming):
     context.enable_streaming = enable_streaming == 'enabled'
@@ -353,7 +370,10 @@ def step_n_ubatch(context, n_ubatch):
 
 @step('{seed:d} as seed')
 def step_seed(context, seed):
-    context.seed = seed
+    if context.seed is None:
+        context.seed = [seed]
+    else:
+        context.seed.append(seed)
 
 
 @step('a prefix prompt')
@@ -413,7 +433,9 @@ async def step_oai_chat_completions(context, api_error):
     if context.debug:
         print(f"Submitting OAI compatible completions request...")
     expect_api_error = api_error == 'raised'
+    seeds = await completions_seed(context, num_seeds=1),
     completion = await oai_chat_completions(context.prompts.pop(),
+                                            seeds[0] if seeds is not None else seeds,
                                             context.system_prompt,
                                             context.base_url,
                                             '/v1/chat',
@@ -429,8 +451,6 @@ async def step_oai_chat_completions(context, api_error):
                                             response_format=context.response_format
                                             if hasattr(context, 'response_format') else None,
 
-                                            seed=await completions_seed(context),
-
                                             user_api_key=context.user_api_key
                                             if hasattr(context, 'user_api_key') else None,
 
@@ -457,10 +477,21 @@ def step_a_prompt_prompt(context, prompt):
     context.n_prompts = len(context.prompts)
 
 
+@step('{num_prompts:d} prompts {prompt} with seed {seed:d}')
+def step_many_prompts(context, num_prompts, prompt, seed):
+    if context.seed is None:
+        context.seed = []
+    for _ in range(num_prompts):
+        context.seed.append(seed)
+        context.prompts.append(prompt)
+    context.n_prompts = len(context.prompts)
+
+
 @step('concurrent completion requests')
 @async_run_until_complete()
 async def step_concurrent_completion_requests(context):
-    await concurrent_requests(context,
+    await concurrent_requests(
+        context,
         request_completion,
         # prompt is inserted automatically
         context.base_url,
@@ -468,9 +499,9 @@ async def step_concurrent_completion_requests(context):
         prompt_prefix=context.prompt_prefix,
         prompt_suffix=context.prompt_suffix,
         n_predict=context.n_predict if hasattr(context, 'n_predict') else None,
-                              seed=await completions_seed(context),
+        user_api_key=context.user_api_key if hasattr(context, 'user_api_key') else None,
-                              user_api_key=context.user_api_key if hasattr(context,
+        temperature=context.temperature,
-                                                                           'user_api_key') else None)
+    )
 
 
 @step('concurrent OAI completions requests')
@@ -490,7 +521,6 @@ async def step_oai_chat_completions(context):
                               if hasattr(context, 'enable_streaming') else None,
                               response_format=context.response_format
                               if hasattr(context, 'response_format') else None,
-                              seed=await completions_seed(context),
                               user_api_key=context.user_api_key
                               if hasattr(context, 'user_api_key') else None)
 
@@ -512,10 +542,6 @@ async def step_oai_chat_completions(context):
                               if hasattr(context, 'enable_streaming') else None,
                               response_format=context.response_format
                               if hasattr(context, 'response_format') else None,
-                              seed=context.seed
-                              if hasattr(context, 'seed') else
-                              context.server_seed
-                              if hasattr(context, 'server_seed') else None,
                               user_api_key=context.user_api_key
                               if hasattr(context, 'user_api_key') else None)
 
@@ -544,7 +570,7 @@ async def all_prompts_are_predicted(context, expected_predicted_n=None):
 @async_run_until_complete
 async def step_compute_embedding(context):
     context.n_prompts = 1
-    context.embeddings = await request_embedding(context_text(context), base_url=context.base_url)
+    context.embeddings = await request_embedding(context_text(context), None, base_url=context.base_url)
 
 
 @step('all embeddings are the same')
@@ -585,7 +611,7 @@ def step_assert_embeddings(context):
 @async_run_until_complete
 async def step_oai_compute_embeddings(context):
     context.n_prompts = 1
-    context.embeddings = await request_oai_embeddings(context_text(context),
+    context.embeddings = await request_oai_embeddings(context_text(context), None,
                                                       base_url=context.base_url,
                                                       user_api_key=context.user_api_key,
                                                       model=context.model)
@@ -594,7 +620,7 @@ async def step_oai_compute_embeddings(context):
 @step('an OAI compatible embeddings computation request for multiple inputs')
 @async_run_until_complete
 async def step_oai_compute_embeddings_multiple_inputs(context):
-    context.embeddings = await request_oai_embeddings(context.prompts,
+    context.embeddings = await request_oai_embeddings(context.prompts, None,
                                                       base_url=context.base_url,
                                                       user_api_key=context.user_api_key,
                                                       model=context.model)
@@ -740,8 +766,9 @@ async def concurrent_requests(context, f_completion, *args, **kwargs):
     if context.debug:
         print(f"starting {context.n_prompts} concurrent completion requests...")
     assert context.n_prompts > 0
+    seeds = await completions_seed(context)
     for prompt_no in range(context.n_prompts):
-        shifted_args = [context.prompts.pop(), *args]
+        shifted_args = [context.prompts.pop(), seeds[prompt_no], *args]
         context.concurrent_tasks.append(asyncio.create_task(f_completion(*shifted_args, **kwargs)))
     await asyncio.sleep(0.1)
 
@@ -781,6 +808,7 @@ def step_server_responds_with_status_code(context, status_code):
 
 
 async def request_completion(prompt,
+                             seed,
                              base_url,
                              debug=False,
                              prompt_prefix=None,
@@ -788,9 +816,9 @@ async def request_completion(prompt,
                              n_predict=None,
                              cache_prompt=False,
                              id_slot=None,
-                             seed=None,
                              expect_api_error=None,
-                             user_api_key=None):
+                             user_api_key=None,
+                             temperature=None):
     if debug:
         print(f"Sending completion request: {prompt}")
     origin = "my.super.domain"
@@ -811,7 +839,8 @@ async def request_completion(prompt,
                                     "n_predict": n_predict if n_predict is not None else -1,
                                     "cache_prompt": cache_prompt,
                                     "id_slot": id_slot,
-                                    "seed": seed if seed is not None else 42
+                                    "seed": seed if seed is not None else 42,
+                                    "temperature": temperature if temperature is not None else "0.8f",
                                 },
                                 headers=headers,
                                 timeout=3600) as response:
@@ -824,6 +853,7 @@ async def request_completion(prompt,
 
 
 async def oai_chat_completions(user_prompt,
+                               seed,
                                system_prompt,
                                base_url,
                                base_path,
@@ -833,7 +863,6 @@ async def oai_chat_completions(user_prompt,
                                n_predict=None,
                                enable_streaming=None,
                                response_format=None,
-                               seed=None,
                                user_api_key=None,
                                expect_api_error=None):
     if debug:
@@ -952,7 +981,7 @@ async def oai_chat_completions(user_prompt,
     return completion_response
 
 
-async def request_embedding(content, base_url=None):
+async def request_embedding(content, seed, base_url=None):
     async with aiohttp.ClientSession() as session:
         async with session.post(f'{base_url}/embedding',
                                 json={
@@ -963,7 +992,7 @@ async def request_embedding(content, base_url=None):
             return [response_json['embedding']]
 
 
-async def request_oai_embeddings(input,
+async def request_oai_embeddings(input, seed,
                                  base_url=None, user_api_key=None,
                                  model=None, async_client=False):
     # openai client always expects an api_key
@@ -1036,21 +1065,31 @@ def assert_n_tokens_predicted(completion_response, expected_predicted_n=None, re
                                                      f' {n_predicted} <> {expected_predicted_n}')
 
 def assert_all_predictions_equal(completion_responses):
-    content_0 = completion_responses[0]['content']
-
     if 'DEBUG' in os.environ and os.environ['DEBUG'] == 'ON':
-        print(f"content 0: {content_0}")
+        for i, response_i in enumerate(completion_responses):
+            content_i = response_i['content']
+            print(f"content {i}: {content_i}")
+    for i, response_i in enumerate(completion_responses):
+        content_i = response_i['content']
+        for j, response_j in enumerate(completion_responses):
+            if i == j:
+                continue
+            content_j = response_j['content']
+        assert content_i == content_j, "contents not equal"
 
-    i = 1
-    for response in completion_responses[1:]:
-        content = response['content']
 
+def assert_all_predictions_different(completion_responses):
     if 'DEBUG' in os.environ and os.environ['DEBUG'] == 'ON':
-            print(f"content {i}: {content}")
+        for i, response_i in enumerate(completion_responses):
-
+            content_i = response_i['content']
-        assert content == content_0, "contents not equal"
+            print(f"content {i}: {content_i}")
-
+    for i, response_i in enumerate(completion_responses):
-        i += 1
+        content_i = response_i['content']
+        for j, response_j in enumerate(completion_responses):
+            if i == j:
+                continue
+            content_j = response_j['content']
+        assert content_i != content_j, "contents not different"
 
 
 async def gather_tasks_results(context):
@@ -1145,9 +1184,22 @@ def assert_slots_status(slots, expected_slots):
                                                 f" = {expected[key]} != {slot[key]}")
 
 
-async def completions_seed(context):
+async def completions_seed(context, num_seeds=None):
-    return context.seed if hasattr(context, 'seed') and context.seed is not None \
+    if hasattr(context, "seed") and context.seed is not None:
-        else context.server_seed if hasattr(context, 'server_seed') else None
+        assert len(context.seed) == context.n_prompts
+        if num_seeds is None:
+            num_seeds = context.n_prompts
+        assert num_seeds <= context.n_prompts
+        seeds = context.seed[:num_seeds]
+        context.seed = context.seed[num_seeds:] if num_seeds < context.n_prompts else None
+        return seeds
+
+    if hasattr(context, "server_seed") and context.server_seed is not None:
+        if num_seeds is None:
+            return [context.server_seed] * context.n_prompts
+        else:
+            return [context.server_seed] * num_seeds
+    return None
 
 
 def context_text(context):